Project Runway Episode Review

Do You Agree With This Week's Winner and Loser on Project Runway?

April 7, 2010

On Monday night's episode of Project Runway, the designers tackled maternity wear as they attempted to dress very pregnant guest judge Rebecca Romijn. (Note: Rebecca and hubby Jerry O'Connell welcomed fraternal twin daughters, Dolly Rebecca Rose and Charlie Tamara Tulip on December 28, 2008.) But, as I mentioned before, I'll take the latest season of PR, even though it was shot ages ago. SO, I really liked the challenge—the models looked hilarious in their fake bellies and it was sweet to see four mums as the judges (Monique Lhuillier sat in for Michael Kors, along with regulars Heidi Klum and Nina Garcia). I also thought the winner and loser were spot on this week, though I don't want to spoil the results for those of you who haven't seen it yet. So what do you think—do you agree with this week's winner and loser?

Photos courtesy of Lifetime

13 Comments

3 years 38 weeks

I am really mad that they sent Melvin home. Mitchell's concept was boring, you can see people walking around in that outfit every day. Also, the execution was horrible. Melvin did go for an unflattering concept, but his execution was impeccable. He reminds me of a young Yamamoto. There was a lot of talent there. I can't help but wonder if they would have kept him if Michael Kors was in the judging. An all women panel can lack perspective.

nutrihuney 3 years 38 weeks

mitchell should have gone home - two weeks in a row he has shown his lack of skill in the sewing room. Malvin showed real promise. ugh... i hate when producers of shows keep folks on just for the drama. I loved Models of the Runway - especially Fatma's reaction to getting picked by Mitchell but I think that had more to do with her being ripped away from Logan.

Lorelei LeFae 3 years 38 weeks

My worry over the show moving to Lifetime has nothing to do with the show itself - I was afraid veiwership would decrease on Lifetime. This doesn't seem to be the case so far.

soulight 3 years 38 weeks

I kind of didn't understand the hysteria of Project Runway moving to Bravo. It was taped and shelved before the court battle as to where it would air. If Bravo would have won, then the same season would have aired anyways. The big test will be next season. Anywho I think they picked the right person to go home. In the first two episodes he seemed to be really struggling and I'm not sure he would have found his footing. I thought the winner's dress was a little boring, but very appropriate which couldn't be said for many of the outfits. And the coat was cute and definitely a plus.

kimretta 3 years 38 weeks

I was really impressed with the winner — I'm impressed that she managed to make a cute dress and that coat! But can Mitchell please go home? He talks a big game, but there's something missing there.

jennaboa 3 years 38 weeks

Mitchell should have gone home; I'm sick of his excuses. I can see where the judges were coming from, but while I wouldn't wear Melvin's design, it at least had a(n overthought) concept. Mitchell's was just ill-made and tacky. You can buy better made stuff at Wal-Mart.

iknowitall 3 years 38 weeks

Are there no more Project Runway Rundowns? :( I looked forward to those.

3 years 38 weeks

I agree with the decisions last night. I thught Mitchell's outfit was well thought, but not well made. If he doesn't step up the sewing skills, he's going to be the next one. Side note: I thought pretty much everyone's outfit was about 4 inches too short. What pregnant woman wants to worry about her ass hanging out?!

fashionplate525 3 years 38 weeks

I think Mitchell should have gone, hopefully next week!

shmoo15 3 years 38 weeks

I also agree with Demarco. Mitchell obviously has no idea what he's doing.

filmgirl81 3 years 38 weeks

I agree with Demarco. I also find the model show afterwards to be rather dramatic as well. Very good season so far!

Lorelei LeFae 3 years 38 weeks

I was really worried about Project Runway moving toLifetime, but honestly, I think this might be the best season yet! All of the designers are amazing and I have loved the challenges so far. I don't think the right person went home last night, but I can see where the judges were coming from. I would have really loved to have seen more of the designer who left. The winner was spot on. I was super impressed with most everyone last night. I also really like that they have integrated the models stretching the Project Runway experience to an hour an a half with the last half hour focused on the models. Very cool. :thumbsup:

demarco11 3 years 38 weeks

Mitchell toooootally should have gone home! I wasn't a fan of Malvin's piece but at least he's creative. Mitchell has messed up two times in a row, badly and it seemed like he was fooling around so much during the time they had to make their look.

13 Comments

You Might Also Like