Skip Nav
Celebrity Kids
Blue Ivy Might Not Be as Big of a Basketball Fan as Beyoncé and Jay Z
Liv Tyler
The '90s It Girls You Wanted (and Still Kind of Want) to Be
Celebrity Vacations
Here's What Barack Obama Has Been Up to Since He Walked Out of the White House — and Our Lives
Accessories
The Way to Make a Fashion Statement Stick

Tobey Maguire Vs Andrew Garfield: We Compare Both Spiderman Films

Spider-Man Head to Head: How to Tell the Difference

View in slideshow
Spider-Man Head to Head: How to Tell the Difference
  • Originally played by: Tobey Maguire
  • This year's model: Andrew Garfield
  • Is the character the same? Yes, with a little bit of a personality adjustment (Garfield's Peter is a little hipper and edgier than his predecessor)
Around The Web
More From POPSUGAR
Join The Conversation
Tabitha3517143 Tabitha3517143 4 years
Andrew Garfield is hands down the best Spider-Man ever! He portrays the comic Spidey more than anyone else has done before. Tobey MaGuire did a okay job and did good acting but the script lacks several elements that made Spider-Man who he really was. Andrew brought Spider-Man alive in ways of comedic fighting, a romantic ladies man, and someone who sticks up for other even without having powers. Andrew Garfield made the character smart and geek out with the science. Tobey's Spider-Man only portrayed a loser boy who is hopelessly and secretly in love with Mary Jane and lacks to show above average brilliance and smarts.
agarfsspiderman agarfsspiderman 4 years
heck no. andrew garfield was by far the better spiderman, and this was the better movie. first off, gwen stacey came first in the comics, so the other movies suck for cutting out her character. second, mj fell in love with SPIDERMAN. she loves peter because he is a superhero, whereas gwen loves peter for who he is, and therefore loves spiderman. third, garfield's peter wasn't just geeky, he was still bullied by his classmates for sure, but he actually stood up to them. and seriously, tobey is wimpy looking, what is he 3 foot two? and you expect us to think a little tiny guy could become all that? sorry, no. Fourth, Garfield is hot. honestly, tobey is just not that good looking, im sorry thats horrible to say but come on, just LOOK at andrew garfield! next, garfield's spidey is hilarious! I was crying laughing most of that movie. he took spiderman's wits and just took it to a whole new level. With the food scene, the "small kinves are my weakness" scene, basketball theme, the organic eggs at the end scene, and just tons more!! And last, the chemistry between Garfield and Stone is amazing. They are together in real life so it makes the movie that much cuter. sorry this is so long...i'm fangirling
Alison-Rice Alison-Rice 4 years
I thought Emma Stone was pretty cute in it... but maybe I was just interested in the on-screen chemistry that lead to the off-screen romance!
Andrew Garfield and Shailene Woodley on Spider-Man 2 Set
Andrew Garfield, Christian Bale, Hugh Jackman and More Hot Superheroes!
Movie Review: The Amazing Spider-Man
July 2012 Movie Releases For Australia
All the Pictures From the LA Premiere of The Amazing Spider-Man With Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield
See Emma Stone's Perfect Style at The Amazing Spider-Man LA Premiere
Emma Stone in White Chanel Dress Pictures at The Amazing Spider-Man LA Premiere
Andrew Garfield Pictures at LA Premiere of The Amazing Spider-Man
Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield in NYC for The Late Show and the Worldwide Orphans Foundation Gala
Emma Stone and Andrew Garfield Pictures Volunteering in NYC

POPSUGAR, the #1 independent media and technology company for women. Where more than 75 million women go for original, inspirational content that feeds their passions and interests.

From Our Partners
Latest Celebrity
All the Latest From Ryan Reynolds