Skip Nav

Can You Keep Your Engagement Ring If You Break Up?

Why Mariah Carey's Still Sporting That $10 Million Engagement Ring Post Breakup


Image Source: Getty / Gotham
If you saw Mariah Carey showing off her engagement ring from former fiancé James Packer and you're wondering why, the short answer is because she can. Though the two have split since their engagement in October 2016, Mariah Carey gets to keep the ring — and that's according to California state law, which protects the individual who didn't call off the engagement. Since Mariah fully intended on marrying James before he called off the wedding, legally, that $10 million, 35-carat diamond is hers.

Unfortunately, other states don't quite see it that way. If you're living in New York, North Carolina, Minnesota, or Tennessee, for example, the rings are viewed as conditional gifts — the condition being the wedding. If that wedding doesn't take place, the gifts must be returned. That said, there are other places like Kansas and Montana, where gifts once given aren't allowed to be taken back — and that includes your engagement ring.

More from POPSUGAR
From Our Partners
Molly Goddard Wedding Dress Collection 2020/2021
Wedding Face Masks for Bride and Groom
COVID Wedding Dress Trends
I'm Letting Strangers Vote on My Wedding Decisions
Rebecca Vallance Launches Wedding and Bridesmaid Dresses
See Lily Collins's Stunning Engagement Ring | Photos
Shop Kim Kardashian's New Skims Bridal Collection
Natalia Vodianova's Ulyana Sergeenko Wedding Dress | Photos
Christine Quinn's Engagement Rings From Kosa Diamonds
Demi Lovato Might Not Wear a White Wedding Dress
See Lily Allen's Engagement Ring and Wedding Band
Photos of Lily Allen's Wedding Manicure
Latest Fashion